Page 1 of 1

Government telling people to change their oil less often?

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 1:01 pm
by E_
Your thoughts?
http://autos.yahoo.com/news/driving-gre ... y%3Dlatest
..Driving green means not changing your oil until you need to
By John Voelcker | High Gear Media – Thu, Jan 5, 2012 12:59 PM EST

When was the last time state tax dollars went toward telling you not to do something?

Ads against drunk driving, certainly. Perhaps ads against smoking cigarettes.

But now, California is embarking on a campaign to persuade its citizens not to change their oil so much.


More modern motor oils, better control of the combustion process through vastly more powerful electronic circuitry, and the persistence of generations-old auto advice have combined to lengthen oil-change intervals.

Yet many of us change our oil more often than we need to.

In California, in fact, roughly half of all drivers change their oil every 3,000 miles—or even more often!—despite manufacturers' recommended intervals for new cars that may be a multiple of that number.

And that, says California's Department of Resources, Recycling and Recovery, wastes oil that could potentially have a far longer life.

According to a story in the Los Angeles Times, the department has launched an ad campaign to encourage owners to be aware of the recommended oil-change interval for their car.

The tagline "Check Your Number," is also the domain name for a website that links owners to a website that gives the the carmaker's recommended interval—these days, often 7,500 to 15,000 miles—for their specific vehicle.

That links to some general advice about what the number means, along descriptions of unusual driving patterns that might require more frequent oil changes. Other more standard advice: Keep your tires properly inflated and switch off the engine if the car is stopped for more than a few seconds.

If every driver moved to the recommended oil-change interval, says a department spokesman, 10 million gallons of engine oil could be saved each year.

The change might as much as halve the amount of money drivers spend on oil changes, which cost $25 and up at quick-change facilities and potentially more at dealerships.

While green concerns aren't necessarily top of mind for many car owners, even in California, the economic argument will likely resonate with lots of people feeling the pinch of the three-year-old recession.

In other words, it's a win-win situation: Driving green means only replacing your engine oil when you really need to, and that saves you money.

Even the shrillest talk-radio hosts may find it hard to fight that one—though we have a sneaking suspicion they'll try anyway

Here are my thoughts. When you change your oil even at 3K if it is black that is CARBON in the oil. Carbon is a very rough substance thus going around through your engine it is making scratches. The older your oil the more carbon. So how often you change it should be up to you. Another thing, MOST people recycle their oil. If anything is mandated maybe that you take it to a recycler should be but not to tell you how often. Also if you are using Synthetic oil you are not using as much crude oil and with some companies you are not using ANY at all. ------- When a state makes my car payments i will follow their so callled car care instructions.. In a bad economy is it not worse for the economy for people to change their oil less often? People that can't afford it are already going to change less often but people that can and want to should be allowed to (if they recycle their oil) since that means more oil bought or more instant oil change places visited which means more jobs and more money flowing through the economy! ;)..

And for this sentence in the question.
When was the last time state tax dollars went toward telling you not to do something?
Really? lol

Re: Government telling people to change their oil less often

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 8:56 pm
by Nervous Wreck
As a mechanic (technician) for the past um-teen years, here is my take:

With the 'new' technology these days and the design of the new engines...
I personally would recommend changing oil every 4500-5000 miles!
That would definately be sufficiant this day and age. JMO of course.

Re: Government telling people to change their oil less often

Posted: Sun Jan 08, 2012 9:10 pm
by E_
Right, but do you want the govt. telling you that? Or telling you 7-14k?

Re: Government telling people to change their oil less often

Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 11:06 am
by katie
I agree with both of you. However, with driving such as it is in So. California especially, I would be changing mine more often than the mfg. recommendations. I don't know if pollution has anything to do with it or not, but I can't imagine that geography doesn't play a big role on the life of oil.

So Cal = daily parking lots on the interstate system along with high temps... I'm not a tech, but I don't think I would be waiting to 7-14 K would be a wise thing to do.

Re: Government telling people to change their oil less often

Posted: Mon Jan 09, 2012 11:09 am
by MattThorn
The trouble there is when people buy crappy cheap oil/filters.

I have often told people that specific brands of oil are "ok" as long as it is changed religiously, but now if they listen to this, they probably aren't going to change brands in this transition.